Sunday, November 09, 2003
Session: Toru Iiyoshi, Senior Scholar/Director, Knowledge Media Lab, Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching: "Inventing the Future of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning: Successes and Challenges"
The "Trinity of Open Education" consists of:
The last, open pedagogical knowledge, is what currently requires development to advance the visibility and sharing of teaching practices, to formulate issues, and to build community through technology. The Knowledge Media Lab helps to turn effective teaching into widely applicable theories, models, and formats (tools and resources), as well as online databases and forums. The scholarship of teaching and learning makes teaching practices visible and public, solicits critical peer review, and facilitates learning from and building on each others' work. The Carnegie Academy for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (CASTL) offers one-year fellowships for faculty. (Has anyone at Furman done one of these?)
The "Trinity of Open Education" consists of:
The last, open pedagogical knowledge, is what currently requires development to advance the visibility and sharing of teaching practices, to formulate issues, and to build community through technology. The Knowledge Media Lab helps to turn effective teaching into widely applicable theories, models, and formats (tools and resources), as well as online databases and forums. The scholarship of teaching and learning makes teaching practices visible and public, solicits critical peer review, and facilitates learning from and building on each others' work. The Carnegie Academy for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (CASTL) offers one-year fellowships for faculty. (Has anyone at Furman done one of these?)
Session: Petra Wentzel, Educational Advisor, Vrije Universiteit: "Wireless all the way: user's feedback on education through online PDA's"
This session was a bit of a disappointment: it consisted of reactions by 16- to 22-year-olds to wireless PDAs, which they were given with little guidance and no real pedagogical innovation. In general, the students liked the PDAs for some things, but felt hemmed in by their constraints and preferred "normal" computers, except when it came to GIS field work, when the PDAs worked extremely well.
This session was a bit of a disappointment: it consisted of reactions by 16- to 22-year-olds to wireless PDAs, which they were given with little guidance and no real pedagogical innovation. In general, the students liked the PDAs for some things, but felt hemmed in by their constraints and preferred "normal" computers, except when it came to GIS field work, when the PDAs worked extremely well.
Current Issues Roundtable: Collaboration
Chaired by Mark Jacobs, Associate University Librarian, Georgetown University
This was an interesting conversation, partly because we had a chance to talk about some common problems in directing student collaborations (i.e., the main one: how to get students to collaborate and not just cooperate?), and partly because Mark had formulated some provocative questions (and I'm paraphrasing): when is collaboration worthwhile and when is it not? When is it a waste of time? When does it water down your vision? The general consensus seemed to be that collaboration is often a kind of political window-dressing that masks what is essentially a cooperative process. True collaboration requires not just a shared vision, but more or less evenly distributed investments in the outcome.
Chaired by Mark Jacobs, Associate University Librarian, Georgetown University
This was an interesting conversation, partly because we had a chance to talk about some common problems in directing student collaborations (i.e., the main one: how to get students to collaborate and not just cooperate?), and partly because Mark had formulated some provocative questions (and I'm paraphrasing): when is collaboration worthwhile and when is it not? When is it a waste of time? When does it water down your vision? The general consensus seemed to be that collaboration is often a kind of political window-dressing that masks what is essentially a cooperative process. True collaboration requires not just a shared vision, but more or less evenly distributed investments in the outcome.
Featured Speaker: Martin Ringle, CTO, Reed College, Winner of the 2003 EDUCAUSE Award for Leadership in the Profession: "Grace Under Fire: Seven Precepts of IT Leadership"
The precepts, briefly noted are:
The precepts, briefly noted are:
- Collegiality trumps courage: Lao Tzu said that a leader is best when people barely know he (sic) exists. It's important to share problems across the larger community.
- Give up immediately and work from there. Let go of presuppositions and work with the "Zen of zero-based budgeting." Be willing start over from scratch.
- The Colgrove Axiom: "You never have as much power as you need or as others believe you have." Or, as Will Rogers put it: "If you get to thinking you're a person of influence, try ordering someone else's dog around."
- The Second Arrow: Train not just to fight well, but to take an arrow, or as many arrows as needed, and continue fighting. (IOW, be obstinate. Hmmm, how does this figure with precept #1?)
- Pan & zoom: Recontextualize the crisis in terms of next week, next month, next year. Take advantage of the opportunities presented by a crisis.
- The Proust Principle: The voyage of discovery is not in seeing new landscapes but in having new eyes. (Minority Report, anyone?)
- No matter what happens, someone will find a way of taking it too seriously.
Session: De Pauw's 361 Degree Initiatives: An Institutional Approach to Transforming Teaching and Learning
A slightly more detailed overview than before. The seeds of the program reach back to the early '90's; it was formally begun in 1996. A $10 million grant from Lilly in 2001 helped to catapult the program into prominence. The program aims to increase integration between administrative and academic computing toward building an academic community. The 361 slogan was invented by students and encapsulates a philosophy of preparing students, not only to be well-rounded ("prepared for every aspect of life"), but dynamic and adaptable through a pervasive approach to information technology. Using technologies to make learning materials accessible for students transforms pedagogy and alters the student/faculty dynamic. Students actively create projects, while technology eliminates the burdensome aspects of learning. De Pauw is currently rewriting its mission to reflect the developments fostered by the 361 program.
A slightly more detailed overview than before. The seeds of the program reach back to the early '90's; it was formally begun in 1996. A $10 million grant from Lilly in 2001 helped to catapult the program into prominence. The program aims to increase integration between administrative and academic computing toward building an academic community. The 361 slogan was invented by students and encapsulates a philosophy of preparing students, not only to be well-rounded ("prepared for every aspect of life"), but dynamic and adaptable through a pervasive approach to information technology. Using technologies to make learning materials accessible for students transforms pedagogy and alters the student/faculty dynamic. Students actively create projects, while technology eliminates the burdensome aspects of learning. De Pauw is currently rewriting its mission to reflect the developments fostered by the 361 program.
Session: Learning Spaces Throughout Campus
Susan Perry presented a summary of insights derived from the recent NITLE workshop on learning spaces:
Susan Perry presented a summary of insights derived from the recent NITLE workshop on learning spaces:
- It's important to build relationships with faculty and senior IT staff, going beyond outreach and into active marketing.
- Plans should be driven by strategic and academic plans.
- Effective learning spaces are driven by the interests of the entire community, not just one group.
- Plan holistically across campus, but be prepared to implement the plan in small steps. (Vassar was cited as exemplary.)
- Each learning space needs a shepherd to see it through, from planning to implementation, preferably someone with fairly neutral interest in the outcome.
- Plan for the future.
- Leave actual technology purchases to the last minute to take advantage of the latest improvements.
- Build prototypes, modify them, and put them through iterations.
- Follow principles of conservation and sustainability to save money.
- Pedagogy must drive technology.
Thursday, November 06, 2003
General Session: Panel on Peer-to-Peer File Sharing: Looking for Win/Win Solutions"
Panelists: Charles Phelps (Provost, University of Rochester) and Graham B. Spanier (President, Penn State), both members of the Congressional Joint Committee of the Higher Education and Entertainment Communities; Cary Sherman (Senior Exec. VP, RIAA); and Jack Valenti (President and CEO, MPAA)
This was an important session from the POV of strategic planning. A quick overview of some key points:
Congress has requested update reports every 45 days from the higher education members of the Joint Committee, warning them that if satisfactory progress is not made in resolving the P2P dispute with the entertainment industry, laws will be passed that "they will not be happy with." Phelps and Spanier indicated that they are trying to leverage cooperation with the RIAA and MPAA to purchase modifications in the DMCA to make it more favorable to the IP concerns of higher education (particularly around fair use). The pressure is on.
There is disagreement over whether universities hold any responsibility for policing illegal P2P filesharing through university networks; a problem with this is its interference with legitimate academic P2P uses and invasion of privacy. There is agreement, however, that universities can take a proactive approach to creating models that will encourage legal forms of distribution. Penn State, for instance, is about to unveil a new music service for students that will permit legal streaming, tethered downloading, and purchasing options from a collection of over 500,000 songs, all covered under student IT fees. Phelps defends such a service as part of the "consumer culture" of college campuses, similar to funding atheletic programs, gyms, and extracurricular activities.
Valenti indicated that the MPAA plans to adopt the Internet as a major delivery channel for movies, similar to the way it appropriated the VCR after initially being threatened by it, but the technology is not quite ready for this approach yet. He waxed eloquent on the need for universities to educate students in the moral values that he sees a key to American culture--honor, duty, respect for property, etc.--in an effort to stem the onslaught of P2P file sharing against the entertainment industry.
It seems that our strategic plan for IT will need to consider this issue.
Panelists: Charles Phelps (Provost, University of Rochester) and Graham B. Spanier (President, Penn State), both members of the Congressional Joint Committee of the Higher Education and Entertainment Communities; Cary Sherman (Senior Exec. VP, RIAA); and Jack Valenti (President and CEO, MPAA)
This was an important session from the POV of strategic planning. A quick overview of some key points:
Congress has requested update reports every 45 days from the higher education members of the Joint Committee, warning them that if satisfactory progress is not made in resolving the P2P dispute with the entertainment industry, laws will be passed that "they will not be happy with." Phelps and Spanier indicated that they are trying to leverage cooperation with the RIAA and MPAA to purchase modifications in the DMCA to make it more favorable to the IP concerns of higher education (particularly around fair use). The pressure is on.
There is disagreement over whether universities hold any responsibility for policing illegal P2P filesharing through university networks; a problem with this is its interference with legitimate academic P2P uses and invasion of privacy. There is agreement, however, that universities can take a proactive approach to creating models that will encourage legal forms of distribution. Penn State, for instance, is about to unveil a new music service for students that will permit legal streaming, tethered downloading, and purchasing options from a collection of over 500,000 songs, all covered under student IT fees. Phelps defends such a service as part of the "consumer culture" of college campuses, similar to funding atheletic programs, gyms, and extracurricular activities.
Valenti indicated that the MPAA plans to adopt the Internet as a major delivery channel for movies, similar to the way it appropriated the VCR after initially being threatened by it, but the technology is not quite ready for this approach yet. He waxed eloquent on the need for universities to educate students in the moral values that he sees a key to American culture--honor, duty, respect for property, etc.--in an effort to stem the onslaught of P2P file sharing against the entertainment industry.
It seems that our strategic plan for IT will need to consider this issue.
Featured speaker: Mark David Milliron, President and CEO, The League for Innovation: "Education in a Connected World: Key Issues in the Balance"
This presentation highlighed the ways in which technology introduces complications and challenges into our lives and emphasized the need for education to cultivate the critical capacities needed to build and sustain a digital democracy.
This presentation highlighed the ways in which technology introduces complications and challenges into our lives and emphasized the need for education to cultivate the critical capacities needed to build and sustain a digital democracy.
Wednesday, November 05, 2003
Session: NITLE progress report: building collaborative programs for liberal arts colleges
This session was a presentation by the NITLE program committee (all the regional directors, plus Clara Yu) of sample collaborative programs. Nancy Millichap (MITC) discussed creating a peer network for instructional technologists among MITC institutions; Suzanne Bonefas described the ACSTC's work in information fluency and software engineering experiences for students; and Bryan Alexander (CET) explained how NITLE works to share and scale common interests, such as GIS, that cut across regions and constituencies, at both the regional and national levels. It's worthwhile remembering the consortial support that's available as we plan.
This session was a presentation by the NITLE program committee (all the regional directors, plus Clara Yu) of sample collaborative programs. Nancy Millichap (MITC) discussed creating a peer network for instructional technologists among MITC institutions; Suzanne Bonefas described the ACSTC's work in information fluency and software engineering experiences for students; and Bryan Alexander (CET) explained how NITLE works to share and scale common interests, such as GIS, that cut across regions and constituencies, at both the regional and national levels. It's worthwhile remembering the consortial support that's available as we plan.
Session: CLAC, the Consortium of Liberal Arts Colleges: Planning and providing partnerships for liberal arts colleges"
Bryan Hoyt from Bucknell described the process they used to create a strategic plan for IT. (Note: Bucknell has a merged computing/information services [library] structure.) The process consisted of the following:
A second presentation in this panel was by Dennis Trinkle, the CIO of De Pauw, about their 361 Degrees program. De Pauw is winning the 2003 Educause Award for Systemic Learning and Teaching for this program. Trinkled explained that the intent of the program--which they began developing in 1996--is to based the vision and mission of the university on a philosophical approach to institutional transformation, which ultimately lead to a reformulation of the university's mission. (Both Mellon and Lilly contributed funding to program development and implementation.) 361 Degrees involves various programs, wide campus participation (pretty much everyone), an emphasis on process, and a fast pace (didn't quite catch the significance of this, but I imagine it has to do with agility). They deliberately chose to focus on "client" relationships rather than "customer" relationships because "client" is more suggestive of partnership and collaboration. (This was an extremely brief introduction to the program; there's a reception tonight at which more information will be available.)
Bryan Hoyt from Bucknell described the process they used to create a strategic plan for IT. (Note: Bucknell has a merged computing/information services [library] structure.) The process consisted of the following:
- Systematically talking to (interviewing) the entire campus. (Shades of Bob.) They did not talk about IT, but asked people what their life would be like in five years, what one thing would make a difference to them on campus, and how they would like to make a difference campus.
- Based on these interviews, they created a plan centered on strengths, challenges and ten goals.
- The plan was inclusive of everyone they interviewed; they made a point of including priorities from every constituent.
- Based on what people wanted, they created a list of low-hanging fruit for immediate use.
- They stressed the importance of listening to everyone, and planning to plan.
A second presentation in this panel was by Dennis Trinkle, the CIO of De Pauw, about their 361 Degrees program. De Pauw is winning the 2003 Educause Award for Systemic Learning and Teaching for this program. Trinkled explained that the intent of the program--which they began developing in 1996--is to based the vision and mission of the university on a philosophical approach to institutional transformation, which ultimately lead to a reformulation of the university's mission. (Both Mellon and Lilly contributed funding to program development and implementation.) 361 Degrees involves various programs, wide campus participation (pretty much everyone), an emphasis on process, and a fast pace (didn't quite catch the significance of this, but I imagine it has to do with agility). They deliberately chose to focus on "client" relationships rather than "customer" relationships because "client" is more suggestive of partnership and collaboration. (This was an extremely brief introduction to the program; there's a reception tonight at which more information will be available.)
Session: Susan Metos and Stephen Acker, The Ohio State University: "Strategies for sharing content and knowledge across campus and departmental boundaries"
The focus was on a knowledge bank created at OSU to facilitate collaboration and distance learning. The conceptual framwork for this tool consisted of the following categories:
An ontology of learning objects provides a landscape of knowledge, within which the academiy works to:
Through these functions working within a landscape of knowledge, a university is "grown" as a collection of "learning ecosystems." Collecting learning objects in a knowledge bank is a way of recognizing and valuing faculty work as intellectual property.
Learning objects are indexed according to the multiple and overlapping contexts that share an interest in them (e.g., biology and history, or computer science and philosophy). Cascading style sheets customized for different contexts automatically tailor learning objects for different audiences and facilitates their reusability. (Note: how they go about determining the relevant contexts for each learning object wasn't clear, but it does appear that human intervention in classifying learning objects is the basic engine of connectivity.)
The focus was on a knowledge bank created at OSU to facilitate collaboration and distance learning. The conceptual framwork for this tool consisted of the following categories:
- data: as collected in a data warehouse or database
- information: as collected in a library
- knowledge: as collected in a dissertation or thesis, an electronic portfolio, a web site, or learning objects
- wisdom: a synthesis of knowledge as collected in a mind
An ontology of learning objects provides a landscape of knowledge, within which the academiy works to:
- transfer disciplinary knowledge
- transform disciplinary knowledge through critical thinking and integration of new information
- transcend disciplinary knowledge by blending disciplines
- transact knowledge by providing students with the knowledge and skills they need
- transmit knowledge from institution to institution and to industry and government
Through these functions working within a landscape of knowledge, a university is "grown" as a collection of "learning ecosystems." Collecting learning objects in a knowledge bank is a way of recognizing and valuing faculty work as intellectual property.
Learning objects are indexed according to the multiple and overlapping contexts that share an interest in them (e.g., biology and history, or computer science and philosophy). Cascading style sheets customized for different contexts automatically tailor learning objects for different audiences and facilitates their reusability. (Note: how they go about determining the relevant contexts for each learning object wasn't clear, but it does appear that human intervention in classifying learning objects is the basic engine of connectivity.)
Featured opening speaker: Shirley Ann Jackson, President, Rensselaer Polytechnic: "Ahead of the Curve: Future Shifts in Higher Education"
Quick summary: It's not (no longer) a matter of trying to keep up with proliferating information, but of assimilating it in complex, creative, and meaningful ways--e.g., in the way that bioinformatics meaningfully integrates recent advances in both IT and biology. There's an increasing convergence of technologies with the sciences, discovery, and innovation, leading to a shift away from specialization and toward multidisciplinarity. Text mining facilitates convergences in the humanities. The trend toward convergence and blurring of boundaries in a way mirrors the "threats without borders" we face today (terrorism, SARS, wildfires, global warming, etc.). The critical task for higher education is to train students in information fluency, critical thinking, and the ability to think in between the boundaries of the disciplines as we know them. Rensselaer is doing this with its new Electronic Media and Performing Arts Center (EMPAC), which combines the sciences, technology and the arts. Jackson aslo bemoaned the shortage of scientists in the national pipeline.
Quick commentary: Jackson's talk centered on ideas that we've been discussing (e.g., connectivity), which is comforting, in a way: clearly, these ideas are in the mainstream of thinking about higher ed. and IT, so we should take them seriously. I was a bit disappointed by the way she linked these ideas to a seemingly conservative view of the role of higher education as ultimately responsible for national security, a vision that seems to reiterate the boundaries that she recognizes, epistemologically, as undergoing transformation. (I'm not suggesting that we do away with the state, but I'd like to hear some recognition that the issue is worth thinking about.) We need to think not only about liberal arts education, but about the role of higher education in general: do we take our cues from the unfolding social, political, and technological contexts unfolding around us? Or do we play a role in shaping those contexts?
Quick summary: It's not (no longer) a matter of trying to keep up with proliferating information, but of assimilating it in complex, creative, and meaningful ways--e.g., in the way that bioinformatics meaningfully integrates recent advances in both IT and biology. There's an increasing convergence of technologies with the sciences, discovery, and innovation, leading to a shift away from specialization and toward multidisciplinarity. Text mining facilitates convergences in the humanities. The trend toward convergence and blurring of boundaries in a way mirrors the "threats without borders" we face today (terrorism, SARS, wildfires, global warming, etc.). The critical task for higher education is to train students in information fluency, critical thinking, and the ability to think in between the boundaries of the disciplines as we know them. Rensselaer is doing this with its new Electronic Media and Performing Arts Center (EMPAC), which combines the sciences, technology and the arts. Jackson aslo bemoaned the shortage of scientists in the national pipeline.
Quick commentary: Jackson's talk centered on ideas that we've been discussing (e.g., connectivity), which is comforting, in a way: clearly, these ideas are in the mainstream of thinking about higher ed. and IT, so we should take them seriously. I was a bit disappointed by the way she linked these ideas to a seemingly conservative view of the role of higher education as ultimately responsible for national security, a vision that seems to reiterate the boundaries that she recognizes, epistemologically, as undergoing transformation. (I'm not suggesting that we do away with the state, but I'd like to hear some recognition that the issue is worth thinking about.) We need to think not only about liberal arts education, but about the role of higher education in general: do we take our cues from the unfolding social, political, and technological contexts unfolding around us? Or do we play a role in shaping those contexts?